rate signatures

we have an avatar one so why not a signature version :3

same rules as the avi thread, rate on a scale of 1-10. cheeky comments optional :p

10/10
I grade in a mathematical scale:
10 points for originality (YO, NEVER SEEN THAT BEFORE)
10 points for concept (WICKED COOL, YO)
10 points for computer tricks (YO NICE TRANSPARENCIES)
I add up the given points and divide by 30, then post the result in fractional form with denominations of 10.

In this case, the concept is excellent, it's really well done in originality, and the glow effect you so often use is a good example of a computer trick, as well as image-mapping.
If I may add a suggestion, the pink on the green Espeon doesn't work too well, but nonetheless it's an excellent signature.

I'm going to make an award for you later, when I feel like MS Painting one. For your perfect score. woo.

9.5/10 nicely donez

10/10 tht guys looks maaaaaaaaad

2.667/10
Five points for originality, because although the layout is original, the items used aren't.
Zero points for conception, because there's no real theme going on in your signature, and also it's really big.
Three points for computer tricks, because the weird dragon thing is animated and transparent. Also, that piece of paper is also pretty cool.
So, 8/30 translates to 2.667/10.

Variant wrote:2.667/10
Five points for originality, because although the layout is original, the items used aren't.
Zero points for conception, because there's no real theme going on in your signature, and also it's really big.
Three points for computer tricks, because the weird dragon thing is animated and transparent. Also, that piece of paper is also pretty cool.
So, 8/30 translates to 2.667/10.

holy beeps ur sick

@ variant

9/10

i like the beatles banner :3
your site link picture thing doesnt show up on the blackness though D:


@ gold

1/10

its way too big

10/10 epicness

2.667/10
Eight points for originality. Even though the picture is from a game, I've never seen it before and it looks beautiful, Also, the quotes are quite humorous.
Zero points in concept. I don't see a common trend in the signature.
Zero points for computer tricks, because really it's just a static image followed by two quotes. Doesn't take much to do that.

...Maybe I should lower the influence "concept" has in my judging.

here what im sying im not going resize anything

it takes up the whole screen on my mac monitor <<;; and its a wide screen. thats way way too big.

i agree and i give kass a 10/10

@Kass
6.667/10
Seven points for originality. Good banner. Really good banner. But, the pets aren't exactly original, as they come from Dragonadopters.
Three points for concept. I'm starting to see a concept of those Dragon things, but it's pretty vague. And the banner has nothing to do with anything else except your name, lol
Ten points for graphic tricks. Animated pets, well-done Photoshop banner. Not much else to say.

@Skorge
LOL WUT

10/10 now cuz i can read the link :3 i like the quote on your banner

6/10 And its uryu i velieve he is one of the two surviving quincies?

uryuu ishida ftw
and i thought he was the last quincy but i could be wrong. i dont get to watch the show very often ^^;


8/10 for a funny warning message

oh come the beeps on isnt ur avatar too wide???

NarutoHeartGold wrote:oh come the beeps on isnt ur avatar too wide???

my avatar? no, its only 140x183
the sig is a bit wide though ^^;; 621x298
ill see about resizing it

i like that you downsized your sig btw :3 9/10

when i said avatar i mean sig silly me lol...and the great naruto sama always pleases the crowd

Espeon wrote:uryuu ishida ftw
and i thought he was the last quincy but i could be wrong. i dont get to watch the show very often ^^;


8/10 for a funny warning message

Well its him and his dad unless his dad died already xD

8/10 naruto :p

9/10 love the pokemon personality thing